Showing posts with label Palmyra. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Palmyra. Show all posts

Friday, September 23, 2016

Art as a Universal Language, Part 6: Art as Social Change


by | Sep 23, 2016 | Art as a Universal Language, Blog | 0 comments




Kara Walker‘s “Testimony” reveals the injustice in African American history

Contemporary Syrian war poster portrays the reality of childhood

In previous editions of this blog, I’ve written about the universal symbolic language of art, and visual art as a mode of communication. One of my greatest interests is how art can be used to instigate social change.  In the 1980s, I was awarded the Raoul Wallenberg Scholarship to study the Israeli/Palestinian conflict.  Once I arrived to study at Hebrew University in Jerusalem, I realized I wanted to focus my research on how art can direct attention to major social, political, and environmental urgencies.





Image by Australian street artist “Meek”, stencil art of his “Begging for Change”

Since the beginning of civilization in Mesopotamia, rulers
used art to depict their elevated status and power. Every
sight-enabled member of the populace understood that the
person depicted largest and closest to the life-giving source 
of the sun, wielded the greatest influence. The social structure
was as simple as powerful=larger; less powerful=smaller.


Victory Stele of Naram Sin, c. 2200 BCE

 
Naram Sin video

When one group overtakes another, it communicates its power
visually, by destroying the most sacred cultural relics of the 
previous culture and supplanting them with visual symbols that
reflect its own ideology. Roman emperors stole Egyptian obelisks
with hieroglyphics boasting of acts of great Egyptian pharaohs.
The Romans erected these obelisks, like cultural hostages, in
front of their own most important structures, to show the 
dominance of Rome over Egypt.  

Likewise, when Christianity replaced pagan spirituality in Rome, 
Christians took this cultural hostage-taking a step further, by 
sticking a cross on top of the obelisk in front of the Roman
Pantheon.  This communicated the ultimate triumph of Christianity, 
over the pagan religions of the past.  This one image of the Pantheon 
below, represents repeated cultural “replacement” from c. 1303, B.C.E., 
to the present day.







Athena, Goddess of Peace and War, intact, in Palmyra 

The same Athena sculpture, after Isis destroyed its head and arms, at end of hall






















































































































Destroyed Buddha of Bamiyan, Afghanistan

The Taliban’s destruction of the Buddhas in BamiyanIsis’s 
obliteration of great artifacts in Nimrud–these acts of 
annihilation are acknowledgements of the ability of 
visual images to communicate messages of cultural 
significance to humanity.  Destroying them is like wiping 
out an entire society’s visual language or history.  It is only 
due to their fear of the power of those spiritual images, that 
the Taliban and Isis chose to destroy them.  Perhaps it is the 
power Buddhism gives to the individual for his own self 
guidance, rather than reliance on an external God, that is so  
threatening to their oppressive rule.

What if, instead of destroying works of art because we fear 
their ability to convey important cultural truths, we embrace 
the power of art to help unite turbulent societies? 
In our current environment of incredibly oppressive, 
xenophobic rhetoric, art can--literally--show us a different 
way.  It can present concept and leave the creativity of 
solution to each individual viewer.


Israeli artist Drew Tal grew up in Israel in the 1960s, when the 
country was a mixture of many diverse cultures.  Rather than 
narrowing his perspective due to religious or political differences, 
Tal is fascinated by different customs and beliefs.  He uses his 
photographs to mirror human realities in a neutral manner.  

In his “Revelation”, Tal gives the brave words “I Am” to 
Muslim woman who could be considered voiceless.  He allows us 
to perceive her individuality in a sea of imposed homogeneity.  
In presenting this unidentifiable woman to us, Tal reminds us that 
while we are so often inclined to define people by their larger group, 
every single human being is an individual, with the same mother, 
father, sister, brother, relationships we use to define ourselves.

The symbolism in Tal’s “Revelation” is dense.  He “reveals” to 
viewers not only this woman’s individual worth, but he also 
poetically bridges the abyss of misunderstanding between Muslim 
and non-Muslim cultures.  “I Am” is a significant statement, 
appearing in Exodus 3:13–15, when Moses says to God, “If I 
come to the people of Israel and say to them, ‘The God of your 
fathers has sent me to you,’ and they ask me, ‘What is his name?’ 
what shall I say to them?” God said to Moses, “I AM WHO I AM.” 
And he said, “Say this to the people of Israel, ‘I AM has sent me 
to you.’” God

In Tal’s “Revelation”, the “I” singles out an individual from the 
group; the "Am" refers to the universal, shared divinity in every
human being, regardless of political, religious, cultural belief. 
Tal’s art is the kind of imagery that can effect change in the world.

French street artist/photographer, JR, is one of today’s most 
engaging artists, using his art to help people all over the world 
make change.  Rather than just creating images for people to 
ponder, he makes the people themselves into their own art.  
JR takes photographs of people in their communities, or has 
locals photograph themselves, all over the world.  This helps 
people see that they can literally create their own reality, by 
rendering themselves as friend or foe within their respective 
community.   JR won the TED prize.  He asked Israeli and 
Palestinian people to make funny faces, printed monumental 
images of them, and mixed them together on each side of the 
wall separating the two areas.  He uses his art to magnify our 
similarities, rather than our differences.  His art opens our 
eyes to the idea that we can share humor, rather than 
animosity, even in the face of major differences.





















JR’s Inside Out project in Israel


Visual images transcend barriers of specific spoken and 
written language.  Visual language is universal, touching 
each human being on a shared somatic level.  Therefore, 
artists have a unique responsibility to reveal issues we need 
to confront as a global human family. By changing the context 
of these images, visual artists can allow us to “see” a different 
way forward. Art can, in fact, change the world in a positive 
way, if we are open to its messages.

End of Part 6

Tonya Turner Carroll
Turner Carroll Gallery and Art Advisors
Santa Fe, New Mexico, USA
turnercarroll.com

Thursday, October 22, 2015

Art as a Universal Language, Part 1: Why Understanding Visual Art is Essential


As the owner of Turner Carroll Gallery, I spend a lot of time talking and writing about artwork by the phenomenal artists I represent. Lately, I've been consumed by the destruction of some of civilization's greatest artifacts.  Ancient art is one of my passions, and I am devastated to see sites all over the Middle East, one after the other, lost forever. The Buddhas of Bamiyan, Nimrud, Aleppo, Palmyra--all contained visual information that helped us decipher the values and wisdom of the ancient civilizations that created them. With the loss of these artifacts comes the loss of our ability to understand the important messages contained in the history of the cultures that shaped our own.  With these “irreversible acts of annihilation,...the entirety of humanity...loses a piece of its memory as surely as if a slice of our collective brain had been removed by a mad lobotomist.” (Simon Schama, 3/13/15, Financial Times).

•••

Often people remark that they feel visual art is “an inside joke,” filled with its own lingo and mystique.  In reality, visual art is (by nature) the universal symbolic language that can be understood not only by art critics trained in deciphering the meaning of its symbols, but by any human being who cares enough to engage with the image. To ignore the visual image is to make a conscious choice to close oneself to messages other human beings attempt to share.




Cave painting, Rock Shelters of Bhimbetka, India
     
Ancient cave painting, Chauvet Cave

Throughout the history of civilization, humans have told stories visually, to communicate with other humans.  Stone Age cave paintings, Mesopotamian cylinder seals, Egyptian tomb reliefs, Native American petroglyphs, religious icons, political propaganda posters, Communist Era Social Realism, and contemporary images of social empowerment all present themselves as creative manifestations of our shared human experience.  




Ancient Mesopotamian low relief image, depicting governance, religion, rites of civilization



Ancient Egyptian relief image depicting love
Human beings have always needed to procure food, governance, emotional connection, and spiritual beliefs to make order of chaotic civilization.  These are the same basic needs human beings possess in contemporary life.  If we take the time to seriously contemplate the art of other cultures, we see that we are one human-kind, and that our similarities far outweigh our social, religious, and political differences.



Thousand armed Avalokitesvara, Budhha of Infinite Compassion
stone Buddhist carvings in Leshan, Sichuan, China.  
(Photo  by McKay Savage)

Navajo drawing by Shemar George

This ancient Chinese carving of Avalokitesvara communicates compassion for all living things. Likewise, a contemporary drawing by a young Navajo boy in the American Southwest uses natural symbols for the four elements to depict the innate harmony of nature.





hl_dandelion11-72.jpg
Hung Liu, China,  “Dandelion 11,”  oil on linen,  2015

Hangama Amiri, Afghanistan, “The Wind Up Dolls of Kabul” 2011

Though from cultures as different as Afghanistan and China, both Hung Liu and Hangama Amiri found the humble dandelion as a symbol of female strength.  Afghan and Chinese cultures might prefer women to be beautiful and graceful, like flowers.  By using the dandelion as an autobiographical symbol in their paintings, these artists show us that while women may be regarded as pretty, fragile, flowers, they are simultaneously strong, stubborn, resilient, and able to spread their essence throughout the world.





Unlike a written or spoken language that takes much time to learn, the pictorial language has immediate impact on both an implicit and an explicit level.  Therefore, if we allow ourselves to engage with the images we see, we can’t help but increase our appreciation for perspectives, cultures, values, and ideas other than our own.  Visual art is the language that helps us realize our interconnectedness in the vastness of the human experience .


This quotation by Mohammed Rabia Chaar, about ISIS's destruction of ancient artifacts in Syria, appeared in the New York Times. "Go and see...how all the ancient (artifacts) have been destroyed and looted, how bulldozers are digging." he said. "The feeling of sickness is growing more and more, day after day….Daesh wants people with no memory, with no history, with no culture, no past, no future."

When we focus on the differences, rather than the similarities, in what the visual language portrays, we disrupt the progress of our global society.  We divide and destroy, rather than enhancing the greatness of humankind.

End of Part 1
Tonya Turner Carroll
Turner Carroll Gallery and Art Advisors
725 Canyon Road
Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501
United States of America